CISCO v Falun Gong

The Supreme Court on Tuesday signaled it may block a lawsuit accusing tech giant Cisco of helping China persecute members of the Falun Gong spiritual movement through surveillance technology.

The case is being closely watched as a measure of how far U.S. courts are willing to go in allowing human rights lawsuits tied to alleged abuses by foreign governments to proceed. A ruling could limit future claims against U.S. companies operating overseas and end a case brought by Falun Gong members more than a decade ago.

The justices are reviewing whether the lawsuit can move forward under the Alien Tort Statute and the Torture Victim Protection Act after a federal appeals court revived the claims, with Justice Neil Gorsuch questioning whether lower courts have left the courthouse door “not closely guarded.”

U.S. Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch speaks at the Nixon Presidential Library & Museum in Yorba Linda, California, on August 9, 2024. (Paul Bersebach/The Orange County Register via AP)

Cisco Systems, Inc. v. Doe I: What to Know

Cisco contends it cannot be held liable under either of the two laws cited in the case: the Alien Tort Statute, an 18th century law that has been used in limited circumstances to bring human rights claims in U.S. courts, and the Torture Victim Protection Act, enacted in 1991 to allow civil suits against individuals who commit torture or extrajudicial killings abroad. The company says neither law permits claims against corporations for aiding and abetting abuses committed by foreign governments.

Much of the questioning from the court’s conservative majority focused on how broadly to rule in Cisco’s favor and whether lower courts are allowing too many similar cases to move forward.

In recent years, the Supreme Court—along with Republican and Democratic administrations—has taken a skeptical view of efforts to use U.S. courts to address alleged abuses tied to foreign governments, particularly when the conduct took place overseas. To counter that skepticism, Falun Gong members have argued that significant aspects of Cisco’s work related to China were carried out in the United States.

Cisco played a major role in designing and building China’s surveillance apparatus, at times with the encouragement of U.S. administrations of both parties. Those efforts continued even as activists warned that the technology was being used to suppress dissent, persecute religious groups and target ethnic minorities.

What Is Falun Gong?

Falun Gong, also known as Falun Dafa, is a spiritual movement founded in China in 1992 that combines meditation and qigong exercises with moral teachings centered on truthfulness, compassion and forbearance. The group grew rapidly in the 1990s before the Chinese Communist Party banned it in 1999 and launched a sweeping campaign to suppress the practice, labeling it an “evil cult.” Human rights organizations and U.S. officials have documented widespread detention, forced labor and torture of practitioners, allegations the Chinese government denies.

Documents leaked in 2008 showed that Cisco viewed China’s “Golden Shield,” a nationwide internet censorship and surveillance program, as a business opportunity. The materials quoted a Chinese official referring to Falun Gong as an “evil cult,” and a Cisco presentation from the same year said the company’s products could identify more than 90 percent of Falun Gong content online.

Other presentations described Falun Gong materials as a “threat” and outlined plans for a nationwide information system to track believers. In their lawsuit, Falun Gong members allege Cisco customized its technology for Chinese authorities despite knowing it would be used to facilitate abuse.

What Happens Next

Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown Jackson appeared more receptive to the plaintiffs’ arguments. Sotomayor suggested Cisco acted as a knowing partner of the Chinese government, saying the company understood the consequences for those being targeted.

Cisco attorney Kannon Shanmugam rejected that characterization, telling the justices the company “vigorously disputes” the allegations.

A decision in the case is expected by late June.

=============================

If you feel powerless to help Gaza, you still has a choice: donate. When so much of what exists is false, authenticity is a powerful weapon we can wield that the state never could. So if you feel lost, hopeless, depressed, angry and afraid, I implore you to return - again - again - and again - to the feeling of love that exists within you that brought you here in the first place. It is only through this that we can remake the world. To redress Gaza’s famine, displacement, and destruction, independent and impartial humanitarian organizations - UN agencies, international and national NGOs - must be allowed to deliver relief at scale. To salvage Gaza’s people from the devastation inflicted by Israel, it must be unified with the West Bank to form an independent and sovereign Palestinian State, not to be parceled and colonized by the former.

Meanwhile, children continue to be shredded by US bombs, and the starvation reaches new depths of hellish collective punishment. If both parties are going to continue to support an ongoing genocide, at least they can both be honest about doing so, rather than having one openly bloodthirsty party, and another—unconvincingly—playing the role of powerless, bumbling humanitarian.

Please keep donate Gaza especially if you, as reader, has [background] International Relation [whatever universities]. IR Graduate means [you must, at least] get some semester [about] studying Middle East [in macro, not specifically Gaza].

We need more people to share fundraisers instead of only talking about Gaza. Some people think that those in Gaza don’t need money but that’s wrong. Almost everyone lost their source of income while essentials, food & medicine get sold for astronomical prices. So I put my attempt in all social media as I can, in twitter / X, in substack [since October 2023 I put link donation], in bluesky or bsky, in threads, in instagram.

Link to donate World Food Programme - Palestine appeal: click here

[Daniel Brühl]

link to donate

Most campaign shared or circulated in social media are for REAL people in Gaza. They’re legit. There are a lot of small campaigns for struggling families. This is their only lifeline. By donating & sharing, you are literally making history and alleviating part of their pain

Please do not rely on me alone for sharing your campaign. I’m only 1 person and sometimes I’m not online which is unreliable. I never ignore anybody on purpose but I have a very limited capacity & very little energy and time.

[Refaat Rafiq Alareer IF I MUST DIE] Refaat Rafiq Alareer was extremely hungry, November 2023, days before Refaat killed by Israel airstrike. If November 2023 already [one-by-one Gazan] extremely famine, extremely hungry, imagine November 2025 or more than 2 years Israel’s Genocide in Gaza.

[RENEW] 455 Languages IF I MUST DIE of Refaat Rafiq Alareer [by 6100+ Translators, Social Media Users]

Prada

·

December 20, 2023

Dec 9th, 2023, New York City, 4.10am —- with update total languages to be 310 as of July 1st, 2024, 3.52am New York City, and then, to be 350 languages as of July 28th, 2024, 1.37am ====== newest update as of July, 3rd, 2025 already 384 languages, and October 8th, 2025 reaches 455 languages across the globe.

Read full story

link donation click here

Thanks for reading Prada’s Newsletter.